Yesterday I asked a question of Cabinet member Paul Taylor:
Can the Cabinet Member provide an update on the Tumbledown Dick
Public House and advise on
Why the premises is not listed and the status of the Council
commissioned report
Why the Council has no planning guidance for the protection of
public houses like the Tumbledown Dick
The consultation arrangements for any planning application
Answer:
Cllr Paul Taylor
"Mr Mayor,
I am well
aware of the high level of interest and feeling that the future of the
Tumbledown Dick has generated in the local community. I am particularly conscious of the Friends
of the Tumbledown Dick campaign and of the many comments expressed on their Facebook
site some relating directly to the Council’s position.
The Council
has sought to cooperate with the Group and has provided a great deal of
information and detailed responses to a range of issues.
As Members
are aware, the property is not currently listed and a formal request to English
Heritage to recommend it for listing has been turned down. In reaching this
decision, English Heritage confirmed that they had taken into account the
outcome of the report commissioned by the Council as well as the report
prepared by the Campaign Group. The
Council’s report was commissioned from a credible organisation, which has
provided advice to the Council is the past on historic building issues and has
experience of working with English Heritage.
The Group has
submitted further evidence to English Heritage and requested a formal review of
their decision – I must stress that this a matter for English Heritage and the
Council has no control or direct influence over the decision.
It is correct
to say that the Council has no specific pub protection policies in place
currently and we are not required to do so, however, in considering any
planning application for the site – and it is important to be clear that no
application has yet been received – I am assured that the references
in the Government’s National Planning Policy Framework to the role public
houses can play in the provision of community facilities and the implications
of their loss, will be taken into account. It is our intention to look at a specific
“pub” policy in the next stage of the Rushmoor Plan. However, the current legislative position simply
allows public houses to become shops without the need for planning
permission.
Finally, Mr
Mayor, I can assure Members that the Council is known for undertaking
comprehensive and meaningful consultation on planning applications, and we will
do this with any applications for the Tumbledown Dick. Quite apart from any pre-application
consultation that MacDonald’s might have chosen to undertake – and this is
recommended by government - the Council will publicise any future planning
application for the site, erect site notices and write directly to affected
parties in accordance with our established policy. I understand the Friends
have been reassured they they will be consulted direct."
Supplementary Question:
‘Could the Cabinet Member explain what happens next following the ‘Asset of Community Value’ designation for the Tumbledown Dick’
"The Council’s
decision to include The Tumbledown Dick on the list of Assets of Community
Value will have no immediate impact. Whilst
there is in place a formal sale agreement the listing has no effect. However, should the sale fall through, for
whatever reason, a six-month moratorium would come into effect if the owner
proposes to sell, during which the Friends could submit a bid to purchase the
site. The owner is however not under any obligation to sell to any particular
bidder."